Controls Leading To Scientific Breakthroughs

Schematic depiction of the key experiments described in the text where the experimental controls failed. The experimental treatments or the lack thereof are indicated on the top of each arrow. Top part of each panel depicts the actual experiment and its result. Bottom part of each panel depicts the failed control experiment (bold). The grey shaded box shows the expected result. On the left part of the red shaded box the actually obtained result is shown, whereas on the right part of the red shaded box the unexpected discovery, that was triggered by the failed control, is indicated in bold letters.

In the Science & Society Essay in EMBO Reports entitled "The controls that got out of control : How failed control experiments paved the way to transformative discoveries" André Schneider (DCBP, University of Bern) analyzes and describes examples how "failed" controls led to breakthrough scientific discoveries. Examples are the discovery of RNA's catalyitic properties, oxygen sensing, RNA intereference and BPA's effect on mice meiosis.

Read the Essay in EMBO Reports (Open Access)
Website Schneider Lab

Figure and title from A. Schneider (2024) EMBO Reports published under a CC BY 4.0 license.